All Salon border patrol Condoleezza Rice Condolezza Rice Department of Homeland Security Dick Cheney Donald Rumsfeld Games George W. Bush Jeff Sessions Joe Gibbs ms-13 News & Politics Paul Bremer Pew Research Center Saddam Hussein Sarah Fabian U.S. Marshals Service

Trump is as wrong on the border as Bush was on Iraq, and it will end just as badly for America

Trump is as wrong on the border as Bush was on Iraq, and it will end just as badly for America

Keep in mind all these weapons of mass destruction that have been sitting there in Iraq just ready for us to seek out them as quickly as we defeated Saddam Hussein? President George W. Bush, Vice President Dick Cheney and Secretary of Protection Donald Rumsfeld recited that abject lie so many occasions our ears have been bleeding by the time American forces crossed the border with Kuwait and took Baghdad.

Then they seemed and seemed and seemed, and what have you learnt, however there weren’t any WMD! Not a single chemical warhead. Not even one bio-weapon. And nukes? Saddam didn’t also have a highschool physics lab degree understanding a few nuclear program. No stockpiles of “yellowcake” uranium. The “aluminum tubes” cited about eleventy-zillion occasions by Rumsfeld and Condoleezza Rice have been for widespread artillery rockets, not nuclear centrifuges. There have been no uranium enrichment amenities. When you swept a Geiger counter over the entire nation of Iraq, it would have registered Zero.

Trump’s lies about immigrants and Bush’s lies about WMDs are the similar factor: justification for corrupt, disastrous insurance policies that waste lives and dollars.

Whereas Bush cited WMDs as the justification for invading Iraq, Trump has bellowed on and on about immigrants and crime to justify his draconian insurance policies on the border, from “build that wall” to taking undocumented youngsters away from their mother and father. To listen to Trump and Lawyer Basic Jeff Periods inform it, undocumented immigrants are accountable for an enormous improve in crime on this nation.

The details are about immigrants and crime are the Trump administration’s imaginary WMDs. In line with the Pew Analysis Middle’s studying of FBI statistics, each violent crime and crimes towards property fell 48 per cent between 1993 and 2016.

The Bureau of Justice, which does an annual survey of households asking if that they had been victims of crime over the final yr, has statistics for the similar interval displaying a drop of 74 % in violent crimes and a 66 % discount in crimes towards property.

In line with the New York Occasions, as the inhabitants of immigrants has risen by 118 % between 1980 and 2016, violent crime has fallen by 36 %.

“The 10 places with the largest increases in immigrants all had lower levels of crime in 2016 than in 1980,” in response to the Occasions, placing the misinform Trump’s claims that areas with giant immigrant communities have greater crime charges. “According to data from the study, a large majority of the areas have many more immigrants today than they did in 1980 and fewer violent crimes.”

Based on the Houston Chronicle, the conservative Cato Institute used knowledge from the Texas Division of Public Security in a research that discovered that undocumented immigrants in Texas are arrested at a fee 40 % under that of Texas native-born residents.

The identical research discovered that discovered that “the arrest rate of all immigrants, documented or not, was 65 percent less than native-born Texans, or 1,243.7 per 100,000,” in response to the Chronicle.

Trump and Periods have regularly harped on MS-13 to justify their harsh insurance policies on the border, claiming that the brutal Central American road gang is smuggling members throughout the border in giant numbers. But in line with the nationwide safety targeted web site Lawfare, “since the Trump administration took office, the Border Patrol has detected fewer gang members crossing irregularly than during the Obama administration.”

In 2017, just .075 % of the complete variety of undocumented immigrants arrested at the border have been MS-13 members, 228 out of 303,916, based on Lawfare.

The incompetence of each administrations is really exceptional. Rumsfeld and his genius fellow “architects” of the Iraq conflict at the Pentagon, Douglas Feith and Paul Wolfowitz, made plans for the invasion of Iraq, however not what they might do as soon as they seized management of the nation.

Rumsfeld famously quipped “shit happens” when requested about the out-of-control looting that went on in Baghdad just days after the Iraq capital fell to American forces. Inside weeks, the thinly-spread invasion drive of about 140,000 was confronted with an insurgency manned and armed by former Iraq military officers and troopers who had been reduce unfastened quickly after after American viceroy Paul Bremer disbanded the Iraqi military.

The American military was so unprepared for the armed opposition they confronted, we have been nonetheless preventing the insurgency eight years later when Obama declared “victory” and pulled out U.S. fight troops. In case you hadn’t observed, we presently have about 5,000 troops deployed in Iraq, and 2,000 preventing in Syria.

The planning by Trump’s Division of Homeland Safety for their disastrous coverage of separating undocumented immigrants from their youngsters over the final two months has been equally out-of-control. “As many as 3,000 children remain separated from their parents, according to new estimates by HHS,” the L.A. Occasions reported this week.

The separations have been a results of Lawyer Common Periods’ so-called “zero tolerance” coverage, introduced in April. This coverage ordered the arrest on Federal fees of nearly each undocumented immigrant picked up crossing the border. It was at this level, in the immortal phrases of Donald Rumsfeld, that shit started to occur.

Just as Bush’s genius warfare planners had no concept what to do as soon as that they had “won” in Iraq, Trump’s genius immigration officers had no concept what to do as soon as that they had taken hundreds of youngsters from their mother and father. Whereas the adults have been despatched to Federal detention amenities to await trial on expenses of crossing the border illegally, the youngsters have been despatched to swiftly organized detention amenities run by the Division of Well being and Human Providers to await . . .  what?

That’s just it. No one knew what to do with the immigrant youngsters, in order that they have been put on busses and despatched to makeshift jails in empty former Walmarts, tent “camps” close to the border with Texas, and god-only-knows what sort of different amenities in Florida, Georgia, Virginia, New York, and Michigan, based on a current report by CNN.

In New York, “at least 239 children are in the care of the Cayuga Centers in Harlem, which runs day programs for them. Some are in foster care, and others could be with relatives,” in line with CNN. Discover the imprecision in accounting for the youngsters in the CNN report, which was based mostly on figures offered by the Federal Authorities. “Some” in foster care; “others” with family members.

In Florida, an unknown variety of immigrant youngsters are being held at a former Job Corps camp in Homestead. In Virginia, an unknown variety of youngsters are being held at a facility in Bristow owned by one thing referred to as “Youth for Tomorrow,” described as a nonprofit based by former Redskins coach Joe Gibbs.

Trump suspended household separations late final month beneath strain by Democrats and a number of demonstrations round the nation. Now the Federal courts have stepped in and ordered the youngsters to be reunited with their mother and father. The issue is that no one appears to know the place the mother and father of lots of the youngsters are, nor do they know the location of the youngsters. The Trump administration went to courtroom this week to request an extension of the order to reunify immigrant households, however the request was denied.

By the court-imposed deadline on Monday, solely 4 of 102 immigrant youngsters beneath the age of 5 had been reunited with their mother and father. “Why was it so easy for them to take our children, but so hard to give them back?” NBC Information quoted Digna, a Salvadoran immigrant who was separated from her two youngsters in Might.

Why was it so arduous? As a result of Trump’s superb Border Patrol and Immigration and Customs Enforcement brokers didn’t hold correct data. Trump and his xenophobic madman lawyer common have been so decided to get their harmful immigrant criminals behind bars and despatched again to wherever they got here from, they didn’t hassle to write down down whose mother and father belonged to whose youngsters.

After years of making an attempt to maintain monitor of the insurgency in Iraq, the Bush administration lastly issued handheld retinal scanners to the American army which they started utilizing to report the identities of Iraqis arrested as enemy combatants, as properly as to determine members of the Iraqi military. The units report the distinctive sample of people’ irises and assign every one to an individual’s id. The moveable scanners can document as much as 10,000 separate, distinctive identities.

Trump’s Division of Homeland Safety might have borrowed retinal scanners from the army, or — right here’s an concept! — purchased their very own! They might have scanned the eyes of every baby and mother or father arrested at the border, matched them to names offered by the mother and father, and in the present day they might have a precise, computerized report of oldsters and youngsters which could possibly be used to trace particular person immigrants proper right down to infants unable to offer their very own names. It will take a number of keystrokes to computer-match the identities of oldsters and youngsters with their bodily places, and a easy, freely out there program like Google Maps might set up the most effective approach to get them again collectively.

This is what occurs when conservatives who don’t consider in authorities take on the activity of operating one. They determine in the event that they inform sufficient lies, and idiot sufficient individuals, they will get away with something. Bush did it when he invaded Iraq on the spurious cost that Saddam had weapons of mass destruction.

Trump appointed incompetent, corrupt cupboard secretaries like Jeff Periods and Kirstjen Nielsen and didn’t require the federal departments answerable for controlling the border to write down down moms’ names and the numbers of the buses you set their youngsters on. In every case, you end up with what we’ve received in Washington proper now: an administration that depends on lies relatively than details and doesn’t worth the lives of individuals whose pores and skin is a shade aside from white, whose faith is aside from Christian.

Individuals have stated separating households at the border is turning out to be Trump’s Katrina. Wrong. Immigration is Trump’s WMD’s, and his disastrous coverage of taking immigrant youngsters away from their mother and father is exposing the President of the United States as ignorant, incompetent, and merciless. Mendacity about immigrants is perhaps retaining his base joyful, however the remainder of the world is watching, and they know the fact.