All Salon Author Interviews authors Books Donald Trump donald trump mental health Editor's Picks Games Justin Frank Mental health Mental Illness News & Politics Trump on the Couch

Psychiatrist Justin Frank on Trump’s “God complex”: He is “erotically attached to violence”

Psychiatrist Justin Frank on Trump’s “God complex”: He is “erotically attached to violence”

Donald Trump evidently believes he is above the regulation. Final week, he fired Lawyer Common Jeff Periods and changed him with Matthew Whitaker, a political operative from Iowa whose solely obvious qualification is his public opposition to particular counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation into the Russia scandal. This is however the newest instance of Trump’s obvious efforts to impede justice.

Trump’s lack of respect for the nation’s long-standing democratic norms and establishments additionally extends to America’s alliances, safety preparations with its allies and associates, and the worldwide order extra broadly. To that finish  Trump has threatened to take away the U.S. from NATO, hailed the deserves of nationalism (whereas barely pretending that doesn’t imply white nationalism), tried to give up U.S. safety to Russian President Vladimir Putin and proclaimed on quite a few events that America will now stand (principally) alone on the planet.

Donald Trump is additionally a recurring liar who is at conflict with the reality and empirical actuality. For Trump the world (and actuality) have to be bent to his will. His supporters love him due to all these traits and behaviors, not regardless of them. Their adoration for Trump is virtually libidinal.

Donald Trump is an authoritarian in ready, who acts as if he believes himself to be God. How does he persuade himself that the principles don’t apply to him? What is the position of violence in Trump’s attraction and energy? Is Trump accountable in some methods for the Pittsburgh synagogue bloodbath and the opposite hate crimes and acts of violence which have taken place throughout his marketing campaign and now presidency? What position does violence play in Donald Trump’s cult of character? How do his obvious psychological pathologies assist him to manipulate his supporters and the American individuals at giant?

In an effort to reply these questions I lately spoke with Dr. Justin Frank. This is our second dialog for Salon. He is a former medical professor of psychiatry on the George Washington College Medical Middle and a doctor with greater than 40 years of expertise in psychoanalysis. He is the writer of the bestselling books “Bush on the Couch” and “Obama on the Couch.” His most up-to-date ebook is “Trump on the Couch: Inside the Mind of the President.”

Our dialog has been edited for readability and size.

In the previous few weeks America has seen an outbreak of high-profile violence and tragedy. There was the obvious hate crime killing of two black individuals in Louisville, the “MAGAbomber,” who tried to assassinate quite a few outstanding Democrats, after which the Pittsburgh synagogue bloodbath. Donald Trump repeatedly failed to reply to these occasions with any type of human empathy or decency. How can we clarify this conduct? 

Trump is unable to handle nervousness. Subsequently, he can’t assist the American individuals handle their nervousness. Trump’s pathology leads him to eliminate every thing that makes him anxious. He impulsively encourages violence. He impulsively is divisive. Donald Trump impulsively externalizes his personal worry of his inside chaos — he has had to wrestle towards this worry ever since he was two years previous. Right here is one other drawback: One of many roles of a president or different chief is to perform as a lawgiver determine, a kind of parental determine for a society. In that means presidents and different leaders perform as a superego determine.

They set the tone for conduct, for morality, for proper and flawed. What Trump has achieved is he has given the superego permission to grow to be violent. He has sanctioned such violence, which is very disturbing. Donald Trump is like an individual who has street rage. However he has the world’s largest bully pulpit and is in a position to categorical this rage in entrance of everybody.

As a result of Trump is president, he has a deep impression on so many individuals. If anybody is unstable or individuals are indignant, even it is justifiable, a pacesetter provides permission to categorical it. It comes and goes in waves. It might have gotten worse due to Trump’s nervousness concerning the midterms. I fear that Trump’s nervousness has translated into even larger externalization of his aggression.

Donald Trump stimulates increasingly more assaults as a result of he has to eliminate his fears of being attacked. He primarily externalizes this nervousness and worry. So many individuals need to argue that Trump is Machiavellian together with his obsession about immigrants and that “caravan” from Latin America — that this is some ploy to get re-elected and assist the Republicans. That’s a part of it, however the primary factor is to handle his personal nervousness. Sadly for us, when he does that, Trump features like a father determine who says, “OK kids, you’re on your own. You can do whatever you want.”

I and others have in contrast Donald Trump to Charlie Manson. He is giving his followers permission and encouragement for violence. He additionally leads a political cult. Do you assume that is a good learn of the state of affairs?

I agree. Donald Trump is the Charles Manson of American politics. It’s essential to see that Trump can have clear arms. He can invite different individuals to categorical his destructiveness so he doesn’t have to carry it out. For Trump, phrases are the equal of weapons. Trump doesn’t want a gun. Phrases are his bullets. He allows different individuals to purchase their very own weapons and fill the barrels together with his tweets and simply shoot individuals. It’s a really disturbing high quality.

Manson is not the one individual you should use for instance right here, nevertheless it is a dramatic means to get individuals to concentrate.

I had a affected person who was on the inpatient psychiatric ward. This affected person used to stroll down the corridor, mild a match and throw it over his shoulder. It turned clear that he needed to set the ward on hearth, however he was going to depart it up to probability in his thoughts. If the match landed and went out, he’d mild one other match and do the identical factor. It was a means of denying duty, psychologically, for him.

That is Trump. Such conduct is the signal of what’s referred to as a thought dysfunction. It’s an indication of an individual who is unable to assume correctly. In some methods it might be a lot better if Trump would simply say no matter horrible factor he needs to. As an alternative, he will get different individuals to do it. He then avoids duty. That type of abdication of thought is what makes Donald Trump, for my part, unfit to be president. He needs different individuals to do the considering and appearing for him. It is  dangerous sufficient for anyone to behave that method, however to have the president of the USA act like that is very harmful.

There is one other significant issue with Donald Trump as properly. When a toddler  has hyperactive tendencies and they’re untreated, an entire cycle of issues can start. This is Trump. It limits not solely his mental improvement, however these issues imply that as an grownup he can also’t pay attention to different individuals. He can’t assume correctly. Trump doesn’t perceive what individuals are saying. It’s not like he doesn’t agree with it. As a result of Trump doesn’t perceive, he subsequently has to retreat to name-calling or going to his base to whip up a frenzy of exercise. Donald Trump on a elementary degree doesn’t perceive complicated points. He has by no means had to take into consideration or grapple with them as a result of it makes him too anxious.

This is why Donald Trump all the time says issues corresponding to, “I have the best words,” or “I’m the smartest person, I know things other people don’t.” Together such comments signal something extremely disturbing. As a psychoanalyst it appears to me that Donald Trump is presenting behavior of what is called “unconscious grandiosity.” Donald Trump is shut to considering that he is God. It’s referred to as the “God complex” and it’s primarily saying, “I know more than anybody else.” At some deep degree Donald Trump thinks he is the deity and he does in reality know greater than anyone else. Trump believes that he is God as a manifestation of a defensive grandiosity, so as to compensate for his ignorance and not likely understanding issues.

There is typically a bent within the mainstream American information media — by no means thoughts his apologists, defenders and enablers — to say that Trump is simply kidding when he talks about violence, that it is all “harmless” political theater. In actuality Donald Trump is not enjoying. All the time consider the autocrat.

Every part Trump says have to be taken significantly. Donald Trump is erotically attached to violence. He is excited when he does these skilled wrestling strikes at his rallies. He is like a toddler. The issue is, Trump has nuclear weapons and he’s the president. Trump’s attraction to violence is not like somebody laughing at slapstick comedy the place an actor journeys and falls down. It is actually a pleasure that’s very visceral and deep and damaging. Trump has had this attraction to violence since he was two years previous. Donald Trump has fixed and constant themes of violence in his speech and conduct. The content material could also be totally different however it is all the time the identical tune. However even with all his distractions, the message is all the time there. It is all the time about aggression, bullying, divisiveness and attacking custom.

Why is there a lot denial within the American information media and the general public at giant about Trump’s threats of violence? It is virtually as if individuals assume that they’ll by some means be exempt or protected from Trump’s threats and people of his supporters.

Once we have been youngsters we had night time terrors. Your mom or father or different caregiver would come into your room and calm you down. The terrors would go away. When the kid grows up they begin organizing these scary ideas and emotions and separating them of their thoughts into good and dangerous. What Trump does is he provides to the night time terrors. He has discovered a method to reactivate them within the American individuals. Trump then says, “I could make America nice once more. I’ll flip on the lights. I’ll make every part OK.”

How can we clarify the handfuls if not lots of of hate crimes and different violence by Trump’s supporters? The SPLC and different teams have documented how Trump supporters, fairly often sporting Trump regalia like MAGA hats, have attacked individuals whereas chanting his identify and slogans. Is that this simply pathology looking for out pathology?

No. Disorganized minds want one other thoughts to assist them arrange their considering, on this case to justify their expression of their anger. When an individual wears one in every of Trump’s MAGA hats they’re primarily dwelling inside their father. Different Trump supporters who categorical their loyalty in comparable methods are additionally dwelling inside their moms. The MAGA hats makes them really feel like they’re subsequently immune from sure sorts of issues, reminiscent of compassion for different individuals. This enables them to id with a damaging aggressor. Trump has permitted and inspired violent conduct, aggression. Trump’s MAGA hats imply, in essence, that his supporters live inside the president.

This is very profound. It is the conduct one sees in cults. As an example, you possibly can have a spiritual cult and the chief is all highly effective. You submit to the whole lot they are saying. When Trump says, “Don’t believe the crap you see from these people, the fake news. What you’re seeing and what you’re reading is not what’s happening,” George Orwell couldn’t say that higher.

What Trump is saying in a primary approach is, “The only way you can be safe is to be on my side and believe in me. Otherwise, you’re going to be attacked.”

How would you clarify the accused “MAGAbomber,” the person in Florida who allegedly despatched all these mail bombs? What is his relationship to Donald Trump?

He is the identical. The MAGAbomber is simply Trump writ giant. He’s following the orders. It’s what you do if you’re in a cult. Keep in mind, everyone in a cult is not on the similar degree of psychological improvement as everyone else in the identical cult. They could all love the chief and revere the chief, however every member nonetheless has their very own totally different psychologies and totally different tendencies to do issues their very own means.

The MAGAbomber is primarily an excessive model of an individual who is saying, “I’m going to do everything Daddy says. I’m going to attack everybody who’s bad. All my neighbors are bad. I’m going to scare the hell out of them and do it.” The MAGAbomber is one model. The bigot who shot up the synagogue in Pittsburgh is one other model. The person who tried to do a repeat of Charleston and ended up killing two black individuals in Louisville is one other model.

Once more, Trump’s music, so to converse, is one in every of hatred, destructiveness, instilling worry. It’s all about dwelling out Trump’s inner conflicts and fears on the world stage. He’s the puppeteer and we’re the puppets. The MAGAbomber is only a totally different sort of puppet.

Trump and the right-wing media’s obsession with the supposed “caravan” of refugees coming from Latin America is one other reflection of the connection between racism, nervousness and violence. How does this work?

As a psychoanalyst, the caravan represents future infants that his mom is going to convey on the earth. Trump doesn’t need any extra little siblings. He doesn’t need any extra individuals to get a bit of the pie. He needs all of it.

Immigrants unconsciously can symbolize future infants who’re a menace. For Trump and people who assume like him, the “caravan” is additionally a mirrored image of the concept black and brown individuals are going to take away white individuals’s jobs. There is additionally a component on this obsession the place the “caravan” and nonwhites are seen as being soiled, human pollution by Trump and his supporters.

Donald Trump was explicitly advised by leaders of the Jewish group not to go to the memorial for the victims of the Pittsburgh synagogue capturing till he renounced white nationalism, anti-Semitism and different varieties of racism and bigotry. In fact he went anyway. Most respectable human beings wouldn’t have completed such a factor. What is going on inside his thoughts? Does he expertise disgrace?

No, however that is the purpose. Once they say, “Don’t come,” to him it’s a problem. Finally, it has nothing to do with the topic. When somebody tells Donald Trump “You can’t do it,” he says, “I’m going to do it.” Donald Trump can’t settle for being advised “No.”

He won’t settle for it. Going to Pittsburgh is simply one other instance of Trump’s defiant streak. This is why he is obsessive about deregulation. He hates any guidelines that restrict him.

If Donald Trump confirmed up at your apply and stated, “I just want to be a better person. People don’t like me. Give me some advice.” What would you inform him?

The very first thing I might say is “Mr. Trump, who loves you? Who do you’re keen on? What’s necessary to you?” I would just get down to basics about life and love, because there’s no other way to deal with him. You have to get through on a deep emotional level and everything else is just noise to him. I would also say to Donald Trump, “Inform me the way you broke your coronary heart.”

He has a number of inner ache.

Sure. Donald Trump has run away from this ache his entire life, and he’s been profitable at doing so. I might immediately tackle that concern very merely, very slowly and really immediately. He would have to expertise a breakdown as a result of he’s prevented all of these emotions his entire life. This is able to be the best way to assist him put issues again collectively in a wholesome method.

Chauncey DeVega

Chauncey DeVega is a politics employees author for Salon. His essays can be discovered at He additionally hosts a weekly podcast, The Chauncey DeVega Present. Chauncey could be adopted on Twitter and Fb.
Chauncey DeVega


Chauncey DeVega


Learn Now, Pay Later – no upfront
registration for 1-Hour Entry

Click on Right here

7-Day Entry and Month-to-month
Subscriptions additionally obtainable
No monitoring or private knowledge assortment
past identify and e mail tackle


Copyright © 2018 Salon Media Group, Inc. Copy of fabric from any Salon pages with out written permission is strictly prohibited. SALON ® is registered within the U.S. Patent and Trademark Workplace as a trademark of Salon Media Group Inc. Related Press articles: Copyright © 2016 The Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials will not be revealed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.